The brewing quarterback controversy between John Beck and Rex Grossman in Washington has everyone’s rapt attention.
Given the ever-present void at the position, it’s not shocking to see the buzz encircling two backup-caliber players who happen to be the only options at the most important position on the field.
Desperation is taking hold.
Offensive ineptitude has plagued Washington for the past 12 years. After finishing second in overall offense in 1999, the Redskins have finished no higher than 11th since (a mark they reached in 2000 and 2005). They had four top-15 finishes and ended up 30th in 2004.
Countless quarterbacks have tried their hand in Washington and not one has bucked the trend of mediocrity. From Jeff George to Donovan McNabb, the timeline of Redskins quarterbacks since Brad Johnson has been less than stellar.
After the McNabb experiment backfired, the Redskins are expected to eventually set their sights on an up-and-coming prospect to take over under center. But this time around, they can’t afford to damage the psyche of another young quarterback like they did with Jason Campbell.
Grooming a franchise QB requires a foundation Mike Shanahan is still trying to work towards. While much of the blame for these offensive shortcomings rests on the quarterbacks and their inability to lead a competent offense, the offensive line has failed to provide that foundation in recent years.
Since 1999, the line has given up 35 or more sacks seven times while surrendering less than 30 sacks just twice. The numbers are far from impressive throughout most of the decade, but the wheels really fell off in 2009. The offensive line allowed 92 sacks the past two seasons and haven’t helped the ground game finish higher than 27th in the league during that time.
Campbell was probably not the answer at quarterback, but we’ll never know for sure given the patchwork collection of linemen in front of him in 2009. The former Auburn star received plenty of criticism for the Redskins’ offensive woes, but in reality, there were few quarterbacks who could have been effective behind that line.
The additions of Trent Williams and Jammal Brown in 2010 did help matters early in the season. McNabb was sacked 16 times through the first seven games of the year before the offensive line gave up 30 over the final nine contests.
Williams had a solid yet unspectacular year; his first as the franchise left tackle. He missed several games with a knee injury, but held his own against some of the league’s best pass rushers in Julius Peppers, DeMarcus Ware, Trent Cole and Mario Williams.
Brown is set to become a free agent when the lockout is resolved and the Redskins will have to decide whether they wish to keep him as he continues to recover from hip surgery in 2008. After Brown missed all of the 2009 season, Shanahan was careful to limit his gameday reps, rotating him with Stephon Heyer at right tackle throughout the year.
Brown told the media he was feeling better in the second half of the season and he did appear more comfortable down the stretch. He played left tackle with the Saints, forcing him to deal with a transition to the right side in addition to his injury.
Washington doesn’t have any other feasible options at right tackle so they would likely need a replacement via free agency if they let Brown walk. He’s 30 years old and will be looking for a final payday so he might not fit into the team’s plans.
However, the most serious concern is how well the interior offensive line will hold up.
Kory Lichtensteiger, Artis Hicks and Will Montgomery will be in the mix at guard as will Florida draftee Maurice Hurt. Surprisingly, Hurt was the only offensive lineman the Redskins drafted despite glaring weaknesses at the guard and center positions.
Casey Rabach is likely to retain the starting center role despite struggling against power players like Barry Cofield and Ndamukong Suh. Rabach is a true professional and a leader in the locker room, but at 33, his skills have diminished significantly.
The offensive line still requires a massive overhaul and though free agency could help Shanahan upgrade one of the weakest units on the team, it remains to be seen if any of the current members—aside from Williams—will fit into his long-term plans.
Establishing the necessary chemistry along the offensive line is a difficult enough task. Add a continuing search for a franchise quarterback and Shanahan will have to endure some sleepless nights as he tries to reverse the trend of offensive futility in Washington.
As his predecessors can attest, it’s a lot harder than it looks.


Recent Comments